Advertiser Disclosure: Review Cafe earns commissions from qualifying purchases.

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

A good pacifier can do a lot more than just provide your baby with the comfort and peace they need. Do you know pacifiers can actually help save your babies from SID? Pacifiers actually stop your baby from sleeping way too deep, ultimately stopping them from SID and other problems of the nature. Now, the question remains, which pacifier works best for breastfed babies? And the answer – with a subtle drum roll in the background – lies in the 5 pacifiers we have reviewed in this article.


In a Hurry? Here are Our Top Choices


The 5 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

What we do know is that we have reviewed a variety of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies. If you choose one of the pacifiers we have reviewed here, you surely won’t have to worry about your baby and their comfort.


1. The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier

The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier comes in a pack of two and is designed to protect your baby’s nose. The good part about this pacifier is that it ensures your child sleeps well at nighttime, without having to wake up due to slippage on their pacifier. The easy design makes it convenient for kids to breathe easily, without constantly altering their pacifiers.


This silicone pacifier comes in a one-piece design with no chances of parts falling over or breaking off. The pacifier is made phthalate free, BPA free and latex free. All babies aged between 0 to 3 months can benefit from this pacifier as they breastfeed concurrently. This brand is also present in bigger sizes, if you find your and your kid’s loyalties stuck with it in the long run.



  • Compatible with multiple attachments
  • Enough room for breathing
  • No latex allergies
  • Affordable



  • Hair can stick to these pacifiers


2. NUK Newborn Orthodontic Pacifier

This NUK Newborn Orthodontic Pacifier is meant for babies with colic. Babies with colic need a pacifier to soothe them and calm them down, which is why you can place your bets on this amazing orthodontic pacifier. Due to its amazing shape and design, this pacifier can easily fit inside a baby’s palate.


The NUK orthodontic pacifier is perfect for babies transitioning from breastfeeding. The pacifier comes with silicone material and is heart-shaped. The design ensures that the pacifier dips right under your toddler’s nose, giving the breathing space most babies require.



  • The shape of the nipple helps exercise your baby’s jaw and tongue
  • Nipple soothes babies with colic
  • Easy to breathe through



  • The pacifier might be a bit heavy for some babies


3. MAM Newborn Start Pacifier

This MAM Newborn Start Pacifier is perfect for little babies adjusting with breastfeeding routines. This newborn pacifier is perfect for babies aged up to two months old, and comes in a convenient set of two. The curved shield allows your baby to breathe easily. Your baby can now breathe and suck at the same time.


The convenient grab button at the end of the pacifier makes it easy for you and your kid to handle. The anti-slip surface keeps the pacifier in place and stops it from falling out.



  • Ideal in size for newborn babies
  • Lightweight
  • Nipple is soft like mom’s nipple
  • Sterilizing case included



  • Water can get trapped inside while washing pacifier


4. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

This Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier is perfect for babies currently breastfeeding. One pack of Philips Avent pacifier comes with six baby pacifiers. You don’t have to worry about the quantity as babies aren’t frugal with how they use their pacifiers.


Most parents have over 5 pacifiers available at any given time, so that they can soothe their kid without things getting ugly. The light green color is aesthetically pleasing and sits well with small kids. The pacifier blends in with the surroundings and has a good design.



  • One piece pacifier
  • Made out of hospital-grade silicone
  • Can be used with pacifier clips
  • Base is wide enough



  • Moms often get their fingers stuck inside these


5. WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier

This WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier offers a soothing pacifier made out of medical-grade silicone for all breastfed babies. Attached at the corner of this WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier is a cute little brown puppy to keep your baby in a playful mood. So, by buying this product you get a soothing pacifier along with a cute little toy for your kid.


The weight of the small puppy keeps the pacifier in place, while kids can play with it to remain enthused. The stuffed animal is cute, which will attract most little babies and toddlers.



  • Easy to grab for kids
  • No latex, PVC or BPA
  • Stuffed animal keeps pacifier in position



  • More expensive than other options


What to Look for When Buying the Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies?

Pacifiers tend to vary in style, size and nipple shape. There are numerous factors that you should consider when choosing the best pacifiers. These include:



The first thing you should consider is the size of your pacifier. Since the pacifiers we have mentioned in this article are meant for breastfed babies, they are perfect for babies aged between 2 and 24 months.


Material of Nipple

Nipples on pacifiers are usually made of latex or silicone. Latex is softer than silicone, but some babies happen to catch allergies from it. Silicone gives a more nipple like feeling to kids and is better suited.



The shield is necessary for stopping your baby from sucking the entire pacifier into their mouth. If it weren’t for the shield, pacifiers would be redundant due to their choking hazards. Study the shield of your desired pacifier and see if it matches the size benchmark of 1.5 inches or bigger.